The Silent Whales of Lunar Sea Review
Band | |
---|---|
Album | The Silent Whales of Lunar Sea |
Type | Album (Studio full-length) |
Released | March 24, 1995 |
Genres | Folk Metal |
Labels | Noise Records |
Length | 50:52 |
Ranked | #107 for 1995 , #5,675 all-time |
Album rating : 86.7 / 100
Votes : 3 (1 review)
Votes : 3 (1 review)
October 11, 2022
“The Silent Whales of Lunar Sea” marks the 4th album in a row Skyclad have taken the spot for best Folk Metal album. Despite creating the genre on their sophomore album years prior, not many other bands really contributed much to the scene! And so Skyclad are still reigning at the top with their tried-and-true Thrash-influenced Folky Heavy Metal.
This album has a little progress and change from their last effort, mostly in the fact that each song has a bit of a distinctive style, with different instruments contributing to them, albeit minimally. Opening track “Still Spinning Shrapnel” has one of their catchiest choruses yet, and the violin is quite prominent here. I was hoping most of the album would follow that style, but unfortunately this album kicks off with what is easily the best song. Still, there are fascinating lyrics all over this thing, almost every track has some unique identifiers, and it’s a bit more varied than their previous releases.
The stronger variation here leaves room for lower lows than their more consistent material. Slightly Ambient “A Stranger in the Garden” is a really unique song, but doesn’t do much for me and ends up being kind of boring, and closer “The Dance of the Dandy Hound” is a goofy bluegrass number that ends the album as weakly as possible. “Desperanto” is a great nod to their thrashier roots, but overall the lows of this album make it possibly their weakest so far in my opinion.
This album has a little progress and change from their last effort, mostly in the fact that each song has a bit of a distinctive style, with different instruments contributing to them, albeit minimally. Opening track “Still Spinning Shrapnel” has one of their catchiest choruses yet, and the violin is quite prominent here. I was hoping most of the album would follow that style, but unfortunately this album kicks off with what is easily the best song. Still, there are fascinating lyrics all over this thing, almost every track has some unique identifiers, and it’s a bit more varied than their previous releases.
The stronger variation here leaves room for lower lows than their more consistent material. Slightly Ambient “A Stranger in the Garden” is a really unique song, but doesn’t do much for me and ends up being kind of boring, and closer “The Dance of the Dandy Hound” is a goofy bluegrass number that ends the album as weakly as possible. “Desperanto” is a great nod to their thrashier roots, but overall the lows of this album make it possibly their weakest so far in my opinion.
1 like
Track listing (Songs)
title | rating | votes | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1. | Still Spinning Shrapnel | 4:34 | 90 | 3 |
2. | Just What Nobody Wanted | 4:48 | 87.5 | 2 |
3. | Art-Nazi | 3:42 | 85 | 2 |
4. | Jeopardy | 4:20 | 88.3 | 3 |
5. | Brimstone Ballet | 4:13 | 85 | 2 |
6. | A Stranger in the Garden | 5:27 | 86.7 | 3 |
7. | Another Fine Mess | 6:15 | 87.5 | 2 |
8. | Turncoat Rebellion | 2:06 | 85 | 2 |
9. | Halo of Flies | 5:23 | 90 | 3 |
10. | Desperanto (A Song for Europe) | 3:29 | 90 | 2 |
11. | The Present Imperfect | 4:04 | 90 | 3 |
12. | Dance of the Dandy Hound | 2:29 | 81.7 | 3 |
Line-up (members)
- Martin Walkyier : Vocals
- Steve Ramsey : Acoustic and Classical Guitars, Keyboards, Mandolin & Backing Vocals
- Dave Pugh : Guitars, Banjo Guitar & Backing Vocals
- Graeme English : Bass, Keyboard, Classical Guitars & Backing Vocals
- Keith Baxter : Drums
- George Biddle : Fiddle, Keyboards & Backing Vocals
10,437 reviews
cover art | Artist | Album review | Reviewer | Rating | Date | Likes | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Icon Review (1993) | 100 | 2 hours ago | 0 | ||||
Death Magnetic Review (2008) | 65 | 3 hours ago | 0 | ||||
The Years of Decay Review (1989) | 100 | 4 hours ago | 0 | ||||
Paid in Full Review (2022) | 75 | 12 hours ago | 0 | ||||
A Prelude to Sorrow Review (2018) | 80 | 12 hours ago | 0 | ||||
Reborn Review (2018) | 80 | 13 hours ago | 0 | ||||
Forests of Witchery Review (1996) | 80 | 18 hours ago | 0 | ||||
Seasons in the Abyss Review (1990) | 90 | 1 day ago | 0 | ||||
Humanity - Hour 1 Review (2007) | 90 | 1 day ago | 0 | ||||
Eye II Eye Review (1999) | 75 | 2 days ago | 1 | ||||
Awakening from Dukkha Review (2021) | 75 | 2 days ago | 0 | ||||
Killing on Adrenaline Review (1998) | 100 | 3 days ago | 1 | ||||
Chapter 3: Parasomnia Review (2011) | 90 | 4 days ago | 1 | ||||
Time to Be King Review (2010) | 70 | 4 days ago | 0 | ||||
The Winter Wake Review (2006) | 75 | 4 days ago | 0 | ||||
Endless Review (2024) | 90 | 5 days ago | 1 | ||||
Forevermore Review (2011) | 70 | 6 days ago | 0 | ||||
80 | 6 days ago | 1 | |||||
90 | 7 days ago | 0 | |||||
Distance Over Time Review (2019) | 80 | 7 days ago | 1 |
▶ The Silent Whales of Lunar Sea Review (1995)
SilentScream213 75/100
Oct 11, 2022 Likes : 1
“The Silent Whales of Lunar Sea” marks the 4th album in a row Skyclad have taken the spot for best Folk Metal album. Despite creating the genre on their sophomore album years prior, not many other bands really contributed much to the scene! And so Skyclad are still reigning at the top with their tried-and-true Thrash-influenced Folky Heavy Metal.
This album has a little ...
Rock'nRolf 90/100
Mar 22, 2017 Likes : 1
사실상 포크 메탈의 원초가 되는 앨범! 마틴 워키어가 스래쉬 밴드 사바트(Sabbat) 의 보컬이었고 다른 멤버들 역시 스래쉬 밴드 D.A.M 출신이었기 때문에 사운드 역시 스래쉬 메탈을 기반으로 한다.
다만 바이올린 주자를 정식으로 영입하여 테마 멜로디 일부를 바이올린으로 대체했고 기... Read More