Log In
Register

Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death) Review

Marilyn Manson - Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death)
Band
Albumpreview 

Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death)

TypeAlbum (Studio full-length)
Released
GenresIndustrial Rock, Industrial Metal
LabelsNothing Records, Interscope Records
Length1:09:11
Ranked#17 for 2000 , #627 all-time
Album rating :  90.2 / 100
Votes :  25  (3 reviews)
Reviewer :  level 12         Rating :  85 / 100
Marilyn Manson’s third album in his original triptych, although chronologically this is the first in the story. A myriad of drama surrounds this album, with the columbine massacre occurring the previous year in which Manson was blamed. The album and concept is deeply layered within a tale exploring celebrity, consumerism, death, and much more. But writing about the history, context, and story of the album could fill a research paper – and you can find it all on Wikipedia anyway – so I’ll write instead about how I feel about the music.

The album opens with many of the most “normal” sounding songs that would become classics defining the band’s sound. “The love Song,” “The Fight Song,” and “Disposable Teens” are all the most easily consumed and straightforward Rock songs on the album. They’ve got a driving, darkly uplifting aura to them like a call to arms for disenfranchised misfits. Not my favorite songs on the album, but they do a great job opening things up.

It gets a lot more interesting in the next chapter. “Target Audience” is darker, gloomier, and heavier, and title track “In the Shadow of the Valley of Death” is plainly one of the most depressing songs I’ve ever heard, and remains among my top 5 Manson songs of all time. Perfect atmosphere and emotion on that track. The following two tracks in the second chapter explore a more weird and artsy direction for the album.

The third chapter is my favorite. It’s got the anthemic “The Nobodies,” the beautifully sad “Lamb of God,” and the most aggressive track on the album “Burning Flag.” This chapter is the most consistent with zero filler, all the tracks are memorable, unique, and full of passion. The fourth and final chapter contains the magnificent “Coma Black,” a sequel (or prequel actually) to Mechanical Animals closer “Coma White.” The album concludes in a trilogy of shorter simpler tracks that aren’t as memorable at first, but over the years I’ve come to really enjoy how they flow together and snuff out the burning fire of Holy Wood.

Definitely one of Manson’s best albums, and includes so many of the band’s all-time best songs. Also astounding that despite being 19 tracks long, there isn’t one track I would call filler or bad. A fantastic concept album full of individual tracks easily enjoyed all on their own.
2 likes
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

Track listing (Songs)

titleratingvotesvideo
In the Shadow: A
1.Godeatgod2:3487.811Audio
2.The Love Song3:1694.411Audio
3.The Fight Song2:5596.111Audio
4.Disposable Teens3:0192.510Audio Music Video
The Androgyne: D
5.Target Audience (Narcissus Narcosis)4:1888.810Audio
6."President Dead"3:1382.89
7.In the Shadow of the Valley of Death4:0989.410
8.Cruci-fiction in Space4:5683.911
9.A Place in the Dirt3:3783.18
Of Red Earth: A
10.The Nobodies3:3595.610Audio Music Video
11.The Death Song3:3093.39Audio
12.Lamb of God4:3992.89Audio
13.Born Again3:20908
14.Burning Flag3:219010Audio
The Fallen: M
15.Coma Black5:5889.410Audio
16.Valentine's Day3:3189.410Audio
17.The Fall of Adam2:3482.89
18.King Kill 33°3:1883.99
19.Count to Six and Die (The Vacuum of Infinite Space Encompassing)3:2382.510

Line-up (members)

  • Marilyn Manson : Vocals, Optigan, Mellotron, Distorted Flute, Synth Bass, Keyboards, Piano, Electric Harpsichord, Guitar
  • Madonna Wayne Gacy : Synths, Keyboards, Samples, Bass Synth, Synth Strings, Mellotron, Sound Effects
  • Ginger Fish : Drums, Sound Effects, Keyboards
  • Twiggy Ramirez : Bass, Guitars, Keyboards
  • John 5 : Guitars
10,513 reviews
cover art Artist Album review Reviewer Rating Date Likes
Dead As Dreamspreview9553 minutes ago0
Unknown Soldierpreview7056 minutes ago0
ØØ Voidpreview402 hours ago0
Dawn of Victorypreview857 hours ago0
The Perfect Element Ipreview957 hours ago0
Dead Heart, In a Dead Worldpreview8522 hours ago0
Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death)preview
▶  Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death) Review (2000)
8523 hours ago2
Celestialpreview601 day ago0
Brave New Worldpreview851 day ago0
Close to a World Belowpreview901 day ago0
Dopethronepreview551 day ago0
Ascensionpreview951 day ago0
The Inalienable Dreamlesspreview451 day ago0
Tyrants of the Netherworldpreview902 days ago0
White Ponypreview702 days ago0
Blast From the Pastpreview
Blast From the Past Review (2000)  [Compilation]
903 days ago1
Urkraftpreview803 days ago0
Spirit the Earth Aflamepreview753 days ago0
Where Owls Know My Namepreview954 days ago0
Stronger Than Deathpreview605 days ago0
Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death)
level 8 quine8805   85/100
Jul 3, 2021       Likes :  5
마릴린 맨슨의 앨범들 중에서 본인은 Antichrist Superstar, Mechanical Animals, The Golden Age of Grotesque 앨범을 가장 좋아한다. 실제로 그 앨범들은 각각 2위, 1위, 1위라는 빌보드200 성적도 있고... 대다수의 팬들이 좋아하는 The Beautiful People, Rock Is Dead, mObscene 등의 히트 싱글들도 포함되어 있으니- 근데... Read More
Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death)
level 13 BlueZebra   100/100
Jun 11, 2019       Likes :  3
맨슨 최고의 역작. 음악성에서 정점을 찍었습니다. 멤버들 창작력이 그동안 쌓여있었는지 19곡이라는 분량으로 꽉 채웠으며, 라이브에서 단골로 연주되는 곡들이 줄줄이 들어 있습니다. 사이키델릭한 안티 앨범보다 본작에 더 점수를 주고 싶습니다. 흥행은 망했지만. 음침하고 살벌한 멜... Read More
Antichrist Superstar
level 13 BlueZebra   95/100
Jun 10, 2019       Likes :  3
마릴린 맨슨의 전성기가 시작된 기념비적인 앨범. 천재 뮤지션 트렌트 레즈너의 역량 덕인지 전작보다 훨씬 발전된 사운드로 가득차 있습니다. 특유의 싸이키델릭함과 사악함, 노이즈 가득 낀 사운드는 맨슨의 다른 앨범에서 쉽게 찾아볼 수 없는 것들입니다. 모든 작사는 맨슨이 직접 했... Read More
Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death)
▶  Holy Wood (In the Shadow of the Valley of Death) Review (2000)
level 12 SilentScream213   85/100
23 hours ago       Likes :  2
Marilyn Manson’s third album in his original triptych, although chronologically this is the first in the story. A myriad of drama surrounds this album, with the columbine massacre occurring the previous year in which Manson was blamed. The album and concept is deeply layered within a tale exploring celebrity, consumerism, death, and much more. But writing about the history, c...
The High End of Low
level 13 BlueZebra   50/100
Jun 9, 2019       Likes :  2
맨슨의 오랜 팬으로서 도저히 실드칠 수 없는 졸작. 앨범 커버가 간지난다는 것 외에 장점 따윈 없으며, 안티나 홀리우드 때의 카리스마 넘치는 맨슨은 어디갔는지 이펙터로 떡칠했는데 그마저도 고음이 안 올라가 힘들어하는 보컬이 여러가지 의미로 압권입니다. 1번트랙은 그나마 좀 ... Read More
The Pale Emperor
level 13 BlueZebra   85/100
Jun 9, 2019       Likes :  2
맨슨의 사운드는 초창기에 발전을 거듭했습니다. 1집의 거칠고 다듬어지지 않은 날것에서 2집의 사이키델릭함과 사악함으로 진화하고(트렌트 레즈너의 도움이 컸지만) 3집에선 대중성과 음악성을 동시에 잡아냈으며 마침내 4집에서 음악성이 정점을 찍었습니다. 팀 스콜드가 합류한 5집은... Read More
Born Villain
level 13 BlueZebra   80/100
Jun 10, 2019       Likes :  1
전작이 개똥졸작이어서 별 기대를 안했으나 생각보다 괜찮은 작품이 튀어나왔습니다. 전성기 때의 사운드에 비하면 턱없이 부족하지만 다음 작이 워낙 수작인 만큼 발판격 앨범이라 생각하면 못 들어줄 만한 작품은 아닙니다. 1번 트랙 Hey, Cruel World는 전작의 실패를 만회해보겠다는 듯... Read More
Eat Me, Drink Me
level 13 BlueZebra   85/100
Jun 10, 2019       Likes :  1
처음에 그야말로 온갖 욕을 다 들어먹은 발라드 앨범이지만, 다음에 나온 앨범이 워낙 졸작이라 재평가를 받고 있습니다. 곡들의 완성도가 의외로 훌륭합니다. 맨슨 음악에서 찾아볼 수 없었던 고딕 발라드인 1번 트랙 If I Was Your Vampire는 음울한 가사와 분위기로 색다른 매력을 뽐내며, ... Read More
Info / Statistics
Artists : 48,197
Reviews : 10,513
Albums : 173,751
Lyrics : 218,635